Post by Ven on Feb 13, 2012 18:27:59 GMT -5
I didn't know where to place this. >_>; I'll make threads for accepted and rejected trolls later.
This is where we'll post the trolls of potential members to be reviewed and voted on.
I'm going to stick a few rules in this OP first though.
1. Anyone can vote and review trolls
This isn't just strictly for admins to do. We want everyone's opinion on a troll!
2. Give reasons for why it's bad (if it is)
I can't be the only one who hates being told "this sucks the end" without a reason. I want to be able to tell the rejected author why their troll wasn't accepted.
3. Please don't be biased
Allow me to expand on this one a little bit using my fantroll as an example. I get a lot of "oh i don't like snake trolls" or "snake trolls are so over used and bad" or "i'm biased against snake trolls" and they so much as never even look Kollek over. (and if they do what they complain about is pure bullshit, but that's another story.) what I'm getting at is that just because someone has a fantroll that's got things that have been overused by the fandom doesn't make it bad. :3
Okay now I'm going to list things that usually tell if the troll will be godawful.
Relations to Canon trolls/kids
That is just a really big no no. Now, I know someone people get away with the former of that by saying their troll was hurt badly in a FLARP session with Vriska or their Lusus was killed by Eridan. Now I'm really iffy on that, but it's really up to you guys if that's acceptable or not. However, ONLY THE CANON TROLLS INTERACT WITH THE KIDS. CAPS BECAUSE I SEE THIS ALL TOO OFTEN AND IT REALLY ANNOYS ME. /end caps
Blood color that isn't on the Hemospectrum
I'm talking white, gray, black, PINK, rainbow, etc. And I've even seen trolls that have two blood colors, or can change their blood color at will. Yeah no get the hell out of my fantroll making
Mutant bloods
I'm not saying that all mutant blooded character are bad! However they're rare for a reason and usually really written badly.
Trolls with Fef's blood
Because most of these are just a rewrite of Feferi. But like above, they're rare for a reason! Not all of the fantroll empresses/emperors to be are bad though. Just, uh, most.
Mutations mutations mutations
In a society that really really hates mutations, you really need a good excuse for this kind of stuff. And make it believable. Because I doubt a troll with two heads/faces is gonna be running around unculled. (no really, I've seen this. Like really what the ever loving crap.)
That's all I got. If anyone wants to add to this, feel free.
This is where we'll post the trolls of potential members to be reviewed and voted on.
I'm going to stick a few rules in this OP first though.
1. Anyone can vote and review trolls
This isn't just strictly for admins to do. We want everyone's opinion on a troll!
2. Give reasons for why it's bad (if it is)
I can't be the only one who hates being told "this sucks the end" without a reason. I want to be able to tell the rejected author why their troll wasn't accepted.
3. Please don't be biased
Allow me to expand on this one a little bit using my fantroll as an example. I get a lot of "oh i don't like snake trolls" or "snake trolls are so over used and bad" or "i'm biased against snake trolls" and they so much as never even look Kollek over. (and if they do what they complain about is pure bullshit, but that's another story.) what I'm getting at is that just because someone has a fantroll that's got things that have been overused by the fandom doesn't make it bad. :3
Okay now I'm going to list things that usually tell if the troll will be godawful.
Relations to Canon trolls/kids
That is just a really big no no. Now, I know someone people get away with the former of that by saying their troll was hurt badly in a FLARP session with Vriska or their Lusus was killed by Eridan. Now I'm really iffy on that, but it's really up to you guys if that's acceptable or not. However, ONLY THE CANON TROLLS INTERACT WITH THE KIDS. CAPS BECAUSE I SEE THIS ALL TOO OFTEN AND IT REALLY ANNOYS ME. /end caps
Blood color that isn't on the Hemospectrum
I'm talking white, gray, black, PINK, rainbow, etc. And I've even seen trolls that have two blood colors, or can change their blood color at will. Yeah no get the hell out of my fantroll making
Mutant bloods
I'm not saying that all mutant blooded character are bad! However they're rare for a reason and usually really written badly.
Trolls with Fef's blood
Because most of these are just a rewrite of Feferi. But like above, they're rare for a reason! Not all of the fantroll empresses/emperors to be are bad though. Just, uh, most.
Mutations mutations mutations
In a society that really really hates mutations, you really need a good excuse for this kind of stuff. And make it believable. Because I doubt a troll with two heads/faces is gonna be running around unculled. (no really, I've seen this. Like really what the ever loving crap.)
That's all I got. If anyone wants to add to this, feel free.